Are you on the hunt for some delicious organic candy that isn’t full of toxic dyes and artificial flavors? This healthier guide to candy should do the trick!
Organic candy will never be “healthy” but it is made with higher quality ingredients, without synthetic additives that can harm our health. There is absolutely no reason for candy to include Red 40, Yellow 5, Blue 1, High Fructose Corn Syrup, and GMOs.
This blog post has options for trick-or-treating, birthday parties, random sugar cravings, and more. So, read on to find the best candy without those pesky artificial ingredients 2025 offers.
The Best Non-Toxic Candy, in a pinch…
- Best Recycled Packaged Non-Toxic Candy: Alter Eco
- Best Allergy-Friendly Non-Toxic Candy: Surf Sweets
- Best Organic Non-Toxic Candy: Black Forest
- Best All-Natural Non-Toxic Candy: YumEarth
- Best Dye-Free Non-Toxic Candy: Unreal
Candy, oh, sweet candy! It’s that favorite indulgence that transcends age and brings joy to every sweet tooth out there.
From the youngest trick-or-treaters to the young at heart, there’s an undeniable allure in that colorful, sugary goodness.
However, this candy-loving saga has a not-so-sweet side too.
If you consider that Americans purchase nearly 600 million pounds of candy each year for Halloween alone– the equivalent of six Titanic ships– you’ll quickly realize that our sweet tooth causes extreme harm to our health.
If coloring such as red 40 and yellow 5, high-fructose corn syrup, artificial flavorings, hydrogenated oils, and preservatives don’t ring a bell, we’ll explain everything in detail below.
Luckily, 2025’s best organic candy brands have their own delicious non-toxic candy recipes. All are completely free from nasty ingredients, of course.
If you have no idea where to buy non-toxic candy, check out our roundup below.
What toxic ingredients are hiding in most candies?
While many candies are delicious treats, it’s essential to be aware of potential ingredients that might not be the healthiest when consumed in excess.
- Artificial Colors: Many candies use artificial food dyes (Red 40, Yellow 5, and Blue 1) to achieve vibrant colors. Some of these dyes have been linked to hyperactivity in children and may pose health risks.
- High-Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS): HFCS is a sweetener often used in candies and other sugary products. Consuming large amounts of HFCS has been associated with obesity, type 2 diabetes, and other health issues.
- Artificial Flavors: Artificial flavorings can mimic natural flavors but may not provide any nutritional value and could have unknown long-term health effects.
- Partially Hydrogenated Oils (Trans Fats): Some candies contain partially hydrogenated oils, which are a source of trans fats. Trans fats are known to increase the risk of heart disease and should be avoided.
- Preservatives: Certain candies contain artificial preservatives like BHA and BHT, which have been studied for potential health concerns.
- Excessive Sugar: While sugar itself is not toxic, excessive sugar consumption can lead to various health problems, including tooth decay, obesity, and an increased risk of chronic diseases.
Win An Organic Mattress Worth Over $1200!
Times are tough, prices are sky rocketing, and green washing is at an all time high. The SKL team wants to give back to this amazing community by giving away the best-selling Kiwi Organic Mattress from My Green Mattress!
What is the safest candy for kids?
Organic candy is definitely the safest option for kids. Organic candies reduce the risk of adverse reactions to synthetic chemicals commonly found in conventional candies.
Plus, healthy candy brands often use higher quality, more wholesome ingredients like organic fruit juices, fruit purees, and natural sweeteners like organic cane sugar or honey.
What Halloween candy is dye-free?
Unreal offers a variety of candies, including peanut butter cups and chocolate gems, that are free from artificial colors and flavors. They use natural ingredients for coloring.
YumEarth and Lovely Organic makes organic candies that are often dye-free. Their fruit snacks, gummy bears, and lollipops, for example, use natural fruit and vegetable extracts for color.
Another one is Surf Sweets! They produce organic gummy candies that are free from artificial colors and solely use organic fruit juices and extracts for color and flavor.
Lastly, while not exclusively Halloween candy, Annie’s is made without artificial dyes or synthetic colors.
From The SKL Team
We want to note that candy is never going to be a “healthy food” choice for kids. This list simply provides healthier candy options than the traditional candy options out there.
The Best Non-Toxic & Organic Candy Brands In 2025
1. Unreal
The Unreal 3-ingredient chocolate coconut bars are made with organic shredded coconut which is surrounded by smooth, rich dark chocolate.
You won’t find any artificial sweeteners here! Only high-quality, sustainably sourced ingredients and half the sugar.
Gluten-free, vegan, dairy-free, soy-free, non-GMO, and preservative-free – exactly as we like our organic candy.
Price
From $28.48+ For 2 Bags
Notable features
Fairtrade & sustainable ingredients, colored by veggies, Vegan Certified, non-GMO Certified, Gluten-Free Certified
location/shipping
United States, ships to the U.S. Outlying Islands
2. That’s it.
Touted as one of the best organic candy brands, That’s it. offers truffles, fruit bars, crunchables, and many non-toxic Halloween candy options for kids!
They’re crafted from 100% real fruit. No tricks here! Plus, there’s no added sugar.
And if you have allergies to worry about, these healthy candy options have you covered – they’re free from the top 12 allergens.
Price
From $21.99+ For A 12-Pack
notable features
Certified Paleo, non-GMO, free from top 12 allergies, gluten-free, plant-based, no added sugar
location/shipping
Worldwide
3. Pure Organic
Pure Organic layered fruit bars are a fantastic choice for those who love sweet and tart fruit snacks with a commitment to sustainability.
These delicious Non-GMO Project Verified organic candy bars come in a triple-layered, dual-flavored format that will tantalize your taste buds.
Also, they are crafted using fruit and vegetable juices and purees, ensuring a fruity burst of flavor with every bite.
You won’t find any artificial flavors here, which is a big plus for those who prioritize natural ingredients.
Price
$17.99 For 12 Bars
Notable features
USDA Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified, Kosher Certified, Certified Gluten Free, vegan, gives back
location/shipping
Worldwide
4. Justin’s
Want to give trick-or-treaters organic Halloween candy that tastes delicious and is also responsibly made?
Justin’s’ offers a delightful fusion of organic nut butter and top-notch Rainforest Alliance Certified cocoa!
They’re USDA organic and non-GMO project-verified and made with wholesome ingredients.
For those watching their trans fat intake – these cups contain 0g of trans fat.
Price
From $36.76+ For A 12-Pack
Notable features
USDA Organic, Certified Sustainable Palm Oil, Rainforest Alliance Certified, mindfully sourced ingredients, non-GMO, sustainable packaging
location/shipping
Worldwide
5. Nature’s Bakery
For the healthiest double chocolate brownie bars and fig bars, look no further than Nature’s Bakery.
Plant-based, gluten-free, dairy-free, nut-free, and non-GMO Project-Verified, these organic candy options are filled with real fruit for an on-the-go snack that satisfies.
No worries, they don’t melt, crumble or break!
As for the delicious brownies, they are made with wholesome whole grains, and cocoa – so good!
Price
From $29.34+ For A 6-Pack
notable features
USDA Organic, Certified Vegan, Kosher Certified, plant-based, no high fructose corn syrup, nut & dairy free
location/shipping
Worldwide
6. Surf Sweets
One of the best organic candy brands kids choose on repeat – Surf Sweets!
Free from artificial colors, made with organic sweeteners and fruit juice, and packing 100% of your daily vitamin C, this healthy candy is the perfect antidote to any sweet tooth craving.
Instead of artificial ingredients, the brand chose organic fruit juice concentrate, organic cane sugar, and lightly sanded in organic sugar.
Plus, they are free from the top 10 common food allergens, so feel free to add them to your non-toxic Halloween candy list.
Price
From $34.99+ For A 12-Pack
Notable features
Non-GMO Project Verified, Gluten-Free Certified, allergy-friendly, vegan, 1% for the planet
location/shipping
Worldwide
7. Sweet Nothings
From squeezable smoothie pops to superfood nut butter bites, Sweet Nothings has all our sweet needs covered.
Made with organic, simple ingredients like dates, peanuts, and oats, these soft-textured snack bars are a fantastic alternative to satisfy your cravings.
And here’s the kicker – there’s no added sugar.
They’re perfect for any snacking occasion which makes them a great choice for your organic Halloween candy checklist!
Price
From $14.99+ For A 6-Pack
Notable features
USDA Certified, Upcycled Certified, plant-based, no added sugar, gluten-free, no preservatives
location/shipping
Worldwide
8. Annie’s
Kid-approved candy without artificial ingredients? We’ll take it!
Each certified organic fruit gummy snack packs bold, natural strawberry, cherry, and raspberry flavors into fun bunny shapes.
That’s right! These vegan and gluten-free non-toxic candy picks are made with real fruit juice.
You won’t find any artificial flavors, synthetic colors, or high-fructose corn syrup here!
Price
From $9.98+ For 22 Pouches
Notable features
USDA Certified, no artificial flavors/synthetic colors, gluten-free, vegan
location/shipping
Worldwide
9. Equal Exchange
Equal Exchange is the mecca of fair trade, organic chocolates and cocoas, sourced directly from small-scale farmers in Latin America.
Touted as one of the best organic candy brands, they solely use certified organic cacao from the Dominican Republic, Peru, and Togo as well as organic sugar from Paraguay and Costa Rica, and organic vanilla from Madagascar.
Plus, along with bars, they also offer mini bits which double as amazing non-toxic Halloween candy – just saying!
Price
From $45.99 For A 6-Pack
Notable features
USDA Certified, Kosher Pareve Certified, 100% from fair trade co-operatives
location/shipping
Worldwide
10. Black Forest
Black Forest healthy candy has liquid centers that burst with grape, apple, lemon, and cherry flavors.
Yep, these tasty gluten-free and fat-free treats are made with fruit juice – an excellent source of vitamin C.
So, where do these colors come from, we hear you ask?
They derive them from real plant sources such as carrots, blueberries, spirulina extract, and turmeric. How cool is that?
Price
From $6.63+
Notable features
USDA Certified, Fair Trade Certified, non-GMO
location/shipping
Worldwide
11. Emmy’s Organics
Coconut crunch’ems, brownie snaps, chocolate-covered treats – Emmy’s Organics has something special for everyone.
The chewy chocolate-covered coconut bites are made with nut butter and real vanilla.
The brownie snaps are a blend of chocolate and peanut butter chips.
As for the crunch’ems, think delicious sweet, toasted coconut chips. No Gluten, no dairy, no problem.
Price
From $19.99+ For A 12-Pack
Notable features
USDA Certified, Gluten-Free Certified, non-GMO, vegan
location/shipping
Worldwide
12. YumEarth
YumEarth has so many great options!
The YumEarth organic chewys come in orange, lemon, strawberry, and cherry flavors.
In addition to being delicious, these individually wrapped juicy fruit chewy picks are also incredibly healthy.
Plus, you can also find chocolate, lollipops, and hard candies – all made with certified organic ingredients, of course.
In other words, that’s the perfect place to shop for non-toxic Halloween candy!
Price
From $13.99+ For A 15-Pack
Notable features
USDA Certified, non-GMO Verified, gluten-free, allergy-friendly, vegan
location/shipping
Worldwide
13. Lovely Organic
Gather the trick-or-treaters because these organic Halloween candy options will absolutely blow their mind! Lovely Organic’s certified organic collection!
Lollipops, fruit chews, and gummies are consciously crafted, and always gluten-free.
The gummy bears, for example, are made with honey and are gelatin-free!
Flavors include cherry, strawberry, and blue raspberry. No yukky additives, ever!
Price
From $7.99+ For A 1-Pack
Notable features
USDA Certified, non-GMO, vegan, no artificial ingredients, gluten-free
location/shipping
Worldwide
14. Made Good
Made Good’s collection of healthy organic candy includes granola bars, crackers, crispy squares, and cookies drizzled and dipped in chocolate.
Packed with sweetness, reminiscent of those chocolate sandwich cookies we all love but in a chewy, delicious snack, their certified organic bars are not only the ideal non-toxic Halloween candy option but also a fantastic addition to every launch box.
Plus, the B-certified corporation uses sustainable packaging, which is a huge plus.
Price
From $20.69+ For A 28-Pack
Notable features
USDA Certified, Certified B Corporation, 90% of waste being reused, recycled, composted, sustainable packaging, gives back
location/shipping
Worldwide
15. Alter Eco
Organic, non-GMO, fair-trade certified, and responsibly sustainable packaged, Alter Eco’s chocolate empowers farmers and reverses climate change.
In addition to using compostable, recyclable, post-consumer-recycled packaging, the brand also helps its farmers transition to dynamic agroforestry which is a type of regenerative agriculture.
So next time you opt for one of their bars that boasts a range of smooth, complex flavors using only clean, whole ingredients, remember that you help make a positive change.
Price
From $51.99+
Notable features
USDA Organic, fair Trade Certified, non-GMO, contains 100% fair trade ingredients, organic, vegan, recyclable packaging
location/shipping
Worldwide
16. Dr John’s
Dr John’s lollipops and hard organic candy are two crowd favorites.
The flavors included are berry swirl, grape, orange, blue raspberry, peach creamsicle, and cherry loaded with 130% DV of Vitamin C per serving!
As for the shapes, think fun and easy-to-handle oval and tooth-shaped pops.
You already know it: these can easily double as the perfect organic Halloween candy options for the neighborhood’s kids.
Price
From $11.40+
Notable features
Kosher, non-GMO, no artificial colors, flavors, or sweeteners, vegan
location/shipping
Worldwide
17. Bare
Bare uses real fruits and coconuts, baked to crunchy perfection!
Their chips come in an array of flavors. From apple banana and coconut to pineapple!
Plus, you won’t find any artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives because Bare believes that less is more. And we couldn’t agree more.
Price
From $4.98+
Notable features
Non-GMO Project Verified, gluten-free, no added sugar, no artificial colors, flavors or preservatives
location/shipping
Worldwide
18. Torie & Howard
Next up is one of the best non-toxic Halloween candies– Torie & Howard chewie fruities!
Their belief is simple: food tastes better when it’s made with organic, natural ingredients and a commitment to responsible practices.
That’s why their best organic candy is made with USDA Organic and Kosher-certified ingredients and production methods that have a positive impact on your well-being and the environment.
All you have to do is pick your favorite fruit flavor!
Price
From $4.36+
Notable features
USDA Organic, Kosher Certified, non-GMO, vegan, no artificial flavors or colors
location/shipping
United States
19. Probar
PROBAR has been using in-house manufacturing for over 13 years!
The brand offset the most mouthwatering, healthy candy in the form of MEAL, BOLT, PROTEIN, PEAK, and THINS!
The ingredients of choice? Peanut butter chocolate, cookie dough, sea salt caramel, berry blast, raspberry, strawberry and more!
You can freely give them out as non-toxic Halloween candy or keep everything for yourself and your family.
You’ll be surprised with the flavors available, as well as the nutrition needed when I needed food while on the go.
Price
From $19.84+ For A 12-Pack
Notable features
USDA Certified, Kosher Certified, Gluten-Free Certified, non-GMO, vegan, 100% plant-based
location/shipping
Worldwide
20. Koochikoo
Our non-toxic candy list wouldn’t be complete without some lollipops! All organic, sugar-free, vegan, allergen-friendly, of course.
Think of flavors like pineapple orange, fuji apple, pomegranate blueberry, and blueberry lemon.
What’s more, the brand doesn’t believe in high-intensity sweeteners like maltitol, stevia, or monk fruit which can cause digestive upset.
Instead, they use tapioca starch as the base of their healthy candy which provides all the sweetness you need – about 70% as much as cane sugar.
Price
From $49.99+ For A 20-Pack
Notable features
USDA Certified, Certified Vegan, plant-based, sugar-free, gluten-free
location/shipping
Worldwide
21. Ocho Candy
Your quest to find the best organic Halloween candy ends here.
Ocho offers organic & Fair Trade Certified filled chocolate candy bars and minis.
These delicious treats are hand-crafted in small batches using lush, buttery, plant-based, vegan caramels or organic, fair trade coconut “trapped” in a bite-ready dark chocolate shell.
Price
From $24.99 For A 3-Pack
Notable features
USDA Certified, Fair Trade Certified, Vegan Certified
location/shipping
Worldwide
22. Tummy Drops
Formulated by a Board-Certified Gastroenterologist for over 10 years.
Tummy Drops have been the trusted natural name for your family’s digestive health and wellness!
Their secret weapon? Organic ginger & peppermint oil–both known for assisting with occasional digestive upsets!
Plus, these healthy candy picks are made with organic ingredients by Oregon Tilth, GFCO gluten-free, and Kof-K Kosher, so they are completely safe and healthy for all members of the family.
Price
From $13.89+
Notable features
USDA Organic, Certified Organic by Oregon Tilth, GFCO Certified Gluten-Free, vegan
location/shipping
Worldwide
23. Numa
Numa makes naturally healthier taffy and peanut candies inspired by traditional Asian recipes.
With 40% less sugar and 200% more protein, you’ll love the super simple ingredients in these healthy candy options!
The mini peanut butter black sesame bars, for example, are made with black sesame seeds, sugar, maltose (rice, water), peanuts, vanilla extract, and salt. Yep, that’s it!
All natural, low sugar, and high protein snacks.
Price
From $13.99+
Notable features
All natural, low sugar, high protein, vegan, gluten-free
location/shipping
Worldwide
24. Simply Nature
Looking for an easy way to get your daily dose of 40+ fruits and vegetables in just one serving? Enter: Simply Nature.
Packed with vital phytonutrients and antioxidants, these treats aim to help improve your overall wellness and energy with natural whole-food ingredients.
No worries, they have no sugar or additives – just good-for-everything superfoods.
Price
$29.99 For A 3-Pack
Notable features
USDA Certified, non-GMO Verified
location/shipping
Worldwide
25. Wiley Wallaby
To put it simply, Wiley Wallaby organic candy is the best soft and chewy licorice on the market.
The brand packs every treat so full of fresh fruit flavor, that there is less room for the things you could do without.
The taste is absolutely amazing, which is why kids love these bites so freakin much!
Price
From $7.49+
Notable features
USDA Organic, Kosher Certified, non-GMO, sustainable palm oil, vegan
location/shipping
Worldwide
Is organic candy healthier than regular candy?
Absolutely, organic candy is way healthier than regular candy because it is made with organic ingredients, which are grown without synthetic pesticides and fertilizers and are not genetically modified.
And while neither organic nor regular candy is considered a healthy food choice, some organic non-toxic candy brands use higher quality, more wholesome ingredients such as organic fruit juices and purees.
This can result in yummy treats that offer trace amounts of vitamins and antioxidants. The sugar content of both organic and regular candies can be quite high. However, healthier candies don’t include any artificial sweeteners, which is a huge plus.
This was your full guide to non-toxic & organic candy brands!
We have reached the end of the list of 2025’s best organic candy brands kids absolutely love.
While none of these are perfect or as healthy as a homemade treat, they are much better than the traditional stuff at the shops. This only means one thing: you can freely add them to your non-toxic Halloween candy list!
If we missed any of your favorite healthy candy brands, please let us know in the comment section!
Loving the non-toxic holiday content? Check these out below!
